Breathing experiment no. 2

It was to be over a year before my second breathing experiment. This time I used an inexpensive (but absolutely delicious) Spanish garnacha, and conducted the experiment with my wife, my daughter, and her boyfriend. The methodology was the same as described in the previous post. I asked people not only to choose the odd wine out, but also to identify whether it was from the bottle or the decanter. Here were the results:

Person Configuration Choice Identification
A bbd 1 b
H bdd 3 b
B bbd 3 d
S dbd 3 b

Once again I was the only person to choose correctly, and, unlike the last time, I correctly identified the source as well. It would be strange if this trend continued; random guessing would lead to one third the people getting it right in the long run. But it is too early to make a big deal about it. Here are my notes:

Aroma on 3 seemed slightly faded. Palate indistinguishable.

This experiment confirms my hypothesis that one effect of breathing is decreased complexity in the nose.

One thing I worry about is that bottle variation can confound the results of these experiments. So after this experiment I purchased a Coravin™ (for Science!) and will use it next time to decant half of one bottle. Stay tuned.

3 thoughts on “Breathing experiment no. 2

  1. Some wines, by tradition, want breathing while others don’t and all between. Grenache has not been in the let it breathe club, other than extreme versions like Rayas.
    That makes the experiment with Grenache interesting in another way.
    Burgundy, a wine of which we say open and closed frequently, has been a target of the breathing to coax opening up.


  2. What about nebbiolo? Amy I did an experiment with that last week, description coming in a couple of weeks. I’ll try burgundy next. I have a couple that are difficult to get into on first sniff, and then open up beautifully. But I’ve always thought it was me, not them, that was changing.


  3. Pingback: Breathing experiment no. 4 | Wine Experiments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s